Members Login
Username 
 
Password 
    Remember Me  
Post Info TOPIC: Hmmm


Old Hand

Status: Offline
Posts: 93
Date:
Hmmm
Permalink Closed


I had a long chat, quite by accident with someone today who had owned Lurchers amongst other breeds for the past 25+y..he told me some things i had wondered about but discounted as not being a problem, if, we took on a puppy. He said that sighthounds never really stop hunting, the mix of Beddy x Whipet in his opinion was quite a handful. I do want a dog, like the rest that can be allowed off the lead, a dog that doesnt run away..etc..Am i 'barking' (s'cuse the pun!) up the wrong tree here by wanting a Lurcher? Agghrrr...i was glad the person was honest, but i'm now left wondering if i am taking a risk with this mix? He also said that most Beddy x are primarily bred for hunting, and whilst i allow the terriers to do a bit of rabbiting, he wasnt sure that this mix would be able to shut on/off. Thoughts/opinions please..the last thing i want to do is mess around with some dog's future or upset anyone. I'd really appreciate any input on this one.

My main concerns are:
1)The rest of my dogs can be exercised (safely) off-lead they are safe around livestock (we have no sheep near, but we do walk sometimes where there are sheep/cattle in an adjoining field) - the dogs dont ever venture into this field - clearly i wouldnt take any dogs, even safe ones, off lead through a field of livestock.

2)I thought that with proper training that a Lurcher pup could be taught to come back to the whistle as the terriers do? I am nervous of having a dog that will take off and not be responsive.

Basically i have to be as sure as i can be that this is the right decision, i have fancied a Lurcher for the past 3 or 4y..but if its not the right thing to do, i will shelve the idea now. I have never owned a sighthound of any kind, we have only ever owned Terriers and Gundogs, this person said that a Bedlington is a different kettle of fish, they apparently tend to be VERY stubborn and are difficult to control, mixed with a sighthound on a first cross this is a potential handful..


Help!! I just want to make the right decision!

__________________


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 577
Date:
Permalink Closed

When you get a cross breed you hope you get the best of both breeds, but as with anything in nature, you can never be sure. You are just as likely to get the worst terrier traits mixed with the worst sight hound traits. I know plenty terriers/sight hounds, who suffer from 'instant recall' that's to say the instant there is nothing more interesting, they will come when you call, but otherwise you could wait forever for them to respond.furious I've had many 'pre owned' lurchers and they were all very individual characters, recall is always a bit hit or miss. I hope you don't write off your search too soon, experience of owning dogs is invaluable when working with any type of dog, especially rescue dogs. My new girl Bess is glued to my leg when out walking, she has no interest in stock, but when she shot off after a rabbit I didn't expect her to stop and return immediately I called. I let her reach the end of the field then called, once the rabbit was out of sight, she ran back to me. For a lurcher this was very good (in my humble opinion) but the level of obedience you need depends on your circumstances, I would not dream of letting my last lurcher 'off lead' anywhere in town or near sheep, but he was fine out here. Please meet some hounds and get to know them, like terriers and other working dogs, they only want to please, they just need to be shown what is required of them.wink

__________________


Old Hand

Status: Offline
Posts: 93
Date:
Permalink Closed

Awww thank you for such a positive reply, i think i was slightly disheartened this afternoon, but i havent given up yet! Terriers are the same, mine all recall fairly well..but when a bunny is waving at them right in front of their nose..sometimes there is a slight delay in between my whistle going and them returning!!! I have always made coming back to me an exciting thing..i carry all sorts in my pockets from a ball, to treats, tuggy bit of rope, to a piece of rabbit fur..etc(when i go to Tesco and rummage for my change and these things fall out..i get VERY weird looks!!!!)With the Vizslas it was a completely different way of training, their recall and skills to the whistle are now excellent, but i still much prefer my terriers..i like their independance, their spirit etc, which is what i am sure i will love in a Lurcher. I have found training each Terrier has been a different experience..each one has responded differently to different things, and i personally have found this really rewarding. I hope somewhere out there is the right dog for us and us for him/her..it will hopefully all come together at some stage. We are in no hurry.

__________________


Master

Status: Offline
Posts: 211
Date:
Permalink Closed

Abbey what that man told you ties in with what I warned you about re the beddie x. In lurcher circles the beddie x seems to be the most problematic even to extremely experienced lurcher people.It is a type unto itself..... other lurchers are not like the beddie x.biggrin 

Lots of love
Eleanorxxxxx


-- Edited by Leolurcher at 01:03, 2007-07-29

__________________
If I can't watch lurchers running in Heaven...I don't want to go there. http://www.flickr.com/photos/leolurcher/


Old Hand

Status: Offline
Posts: 93
Date:
Permalink Closed

I remember that you said that...what would you all think of a Parson Russell x Whippet..i know both the parents, lovely steady, nice tempered dogs..any thoughts?

-- Edited by abbey at 01:05, 2007-07-29

__________________


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 510
Date:
Permalink Closed

On lurcher recall.  Biscuit is now two years old and good on recall under "normal" conditions.  However, no amount of whistle or shouting does any good if a rabbit, deer, hare etc. crosses his path.  He gets off-lead in quiet places away from roads, so wildlife is inevitable.  He chases until tired or they lose him, and then comes back.  I have to follow on the path he ran down doing the occasional whistle and call, so he can locate me. It can be worrying, but it's the balance of letting a big rangy dog have his time off lead.  I think he would wither if on lead all the time. 

Biscuit is whippetX deerhound and perhaps a bit of collie. He has learned his manners on lead, and we can walk past cats etc., with only some hard stares, but would never trust him with cats.

Biscuit is an angel in the house, very sweet and will listen, and hates to get a row for anything, but outside can be different when the sighthound/prey thing kicks in.

I have to say it's hard work and consistency, but it has been very rewarding - there is nothing like seeing him barrel back to you when you whistle (for the chicken of course!)

Hope you find the lurcher with your name.

Valerie and Biscuit

__________________
Mere beginner


Graduate

Status: Offline
Posts: 24
Date:
Permalink Closed

Hi theresmile  this isn't really advice,just my experience of having a lurcher with a bit of Beddie in her. We got our first lurcher Murphy from Seafield cat and dog home with absolutely no idea of his parentage but as he developed it was obvious he had more than a touch of saluki in him and definitely has a saluki temperament i.e would sleep all day if you let him!! Outside he is born to run and chase rabbits but has NEVER actually caught one and one day we saw Murphy actually being chased by two rabbitsbiggrin
Jazz on the other hand...we acquired her under odd circumstances but we know her parentage. She comes from working lurcher parents-whippetxsaluki mum and beddiexcollie dad so she covers all bases-speed,stamina,intelligence and tenacity. Oh,and sometimes downright bloody mindednessweirdface
What we are discovering with her boils down to the old argument of nature versus nurture and on the odd occasion it seems like a bit of an uphill struggle but she is still only 7months old and really is doing well on the whole!
But Jazz has already caught,killed and eaten several bunnies and definitely has a strong prey drive but lives perfectly happily in a house with two cats and shows no interest in them whatsoever. And on the plus side she generally comes when called,even with the bunny running right in front of her nose. BUT we are finding now that she has started 'hunting' dogs of any size or breedcry she can switch from play mode to 'kill' mode in the blink of an eye but same again,if we catch her before she gets to that stage,she will come back to us quite happily.
I think what I am trying to say is don't let the beddie x put you off-it's a big learning curve for us but hopefully with the right management and consistency Jazz is going to be as great a companion as Murphy,just a very different personality. Dogs are a bit like kids I think. You never know what you are going to get but hopefully with a bit of work and dedication they can turn out to be wee starssmile

__________________
To err is human,to forgive canine....
Page 1 of 1  sorted by
 
Quick Reply

Please log in to post quick replies.

Tweet this page Post to Digg Post to Del.icio.us


Create your own FREE Forum
Report Abuse
Powered by ActiveBoard