Members Login
Username 
 
Password 
    Remember Me  
Post Info TOPIC: Feeding raw bones
FAJ


Enlightened One

Status: Offline
Posts: 1288
Date:
Feeding raw bones
Permalink Closed


I know of a fair few people that feed their dogs on a BARF diet (ie, bones and raw foods) and, whilst I'm not planning on feeding Harry and Pearly this way, they really enjoy the odd meaty marrowbone that they get from the local butchers. They enjoy the crunching and it seems to do their teeth good too.

I'm wondering about giving them the odd chicken wing to crunch on. Would this be safe for them? I have a fear of raw/undercooked chicken, which of course is ridiculous, seeing as they're dogs and their stomachs and digestive systems are made for raw meat.

Anyhoo, I'd be interested to hear whether people do this. And, if so, does anything need to be done to the chicken wing? And would they eat the whole thing?

Fiona

__________________
Disorder, panic, chaos; my work here is done.


GAL Newsletter Editor

Status: Offline
Posts: 1632
Date:
Permalink Closed

Hi Fiona


I think I remember reading that chicken bones can splinter and cause damage to the digestive system, but the article I was reading may have been referring to cooked chicken on the bone. I don't know if raw chicken bones, like the wings, would do the same.


If I was giving Vegas a raw bone, I'd feel safer giving him a marrowbone - either lamb or beef.


Christine



__________________


Graduate

Status: Offline
Posts: 20
Date:
Permalink Closed

We feed all our dogs on a diet of raw meaty bones including chicken wings. They seem to thoroughly enjoy crunching their way through them and it helps keep their teeth clean. Just to be clear you should only ever feed raw bones as cooked bones can splinter and cause damage to the dog. Our vet seems to think that dogs can cope well with this sort of diet, in general what a dog can't digest it throws up.

The first time we fed the hounds chicken wings I was a nervous wreck, I had my mobile with me and the vets number ready to call but they all coped very well.

As with anything there are some risks associated for example a friends dog choked on it's dry kibble, luckily she lives next door to a vet who managed to perform doggy heimlich.



__________________
FAJ


Enlightened One

Status: Offline
Posts: 1288
Date:
Permalink Closed

Hi, Jade - I can appreciate you being a nervous wreck at feeding them a raw chicken wing for the first time! That's how I feel about it. I think both Harry and Pearly would like it, but it's my own nervousness that puts me off. I can't make the transition from cooked bones not being okay, to raw bones being fine. And I worry that their teeth would crack!

Hmm.... food for thought.....

__________________
Disorder, panic, chaos; my work here is done.
C_J


Master

Status: Offline
Posts: 327
Date:
Permalink Closed

Here are a few links about the BARF diet and feeding raw bones. The 'doggienews' one shows both sides of the arguement - health Vs safety.

http://www.thepetcenter.com/imtop/bones.html

http://www.doggienews.com/lib/food/dog-barf.htm

I don't feed Casper bones, I have seen too many accidents and blockages. It's like throwing sticks for dogs - people do it all the time with no accidents, but I have seen many dogs on the operating table with bits of stick in their mouths/throats and to me its just not worth the risk.

...but then I do give Casper rawhide chews and there is a choking risk with them I guess nothing can be 100% safe?!

Jane

__________________
"We make a living by what we get, we make a life by what we give."
C_J


Master

Status: Offline
Posts: 327
Date:
Permalink Closed

The links didn't work - you can just copy and paste them into the address bar and that should work

The 'petcentre' link has some interesting xrays that are worth taking a look at.



__________________
"We make a living by what we get, we make a life by what we give."


Old Hand

Status: Offline
Posts: 75
Date:
Permalink Closed

Like Jade, I feed all my dogs a raw diet  and have done for many years.  Meaty bones form part of this diet but I am careful which bones I feed. 


After having fed dogs on processed pet food  in the past and then, a number of years ago, changing to a raw diet I can say, without any hesitation, that I would not go back to feeding processed dog food. 


Anyone wanting more info about the benefits of feeding raw diet try


www.canine-health-concern.org.uk        and click the link on feeding.


Julie



__________________


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 617
Date:
Permalink Closed

My dog Charlie nicked many a chicken carcass from the bin, to give you an idea we have had to have the bin on the worktop until we lost him in September! He was a real raider and ate tin foil on occasion too. We spent hours worrying and buying new bins in the hope that they would be dog-proof!I too seem to recall that chicken bones can splinter and are dangerous to dogs but he never came to any harm.


Who knows! but I would be careful myself but I am a worrier. Em, Tig and chad X


 


 


 



__________________


Master

Status: Offline
Posts: 465
Date:
Permalink Closed

never feed cooked bones (of any kind IMO). but raw are fine and very good for the teeth.


have you tried it yet? just wondering because i bought the dogs some lovely raw chicken (thighs i think) a few years ago but didn't get the 'gimme that i want it now' reaction i was expecting. some of them were completely disinterested and a couple started to shake and salivate madly (the way they do around any blood). i gave up there and then.


but looking at malcolm - barf seems like a great option. he's a picture of health!



__________________
Best Regards
glendy


Master

Status: Offline
Posts: 122
Date:
Permalink Closed

I've tried the raw chicken on occasion - Oscar wasn't that keen but ate it anyway & Petra loves anything raw! Like you I was at first concerned because of all the undoubted nasties in raw poultry - but one of my bigger problems I suppose is that factory farming methods of these animals and should I be buying factory farmed chickens? I try to buy organic for us, but feel that is a bit OTT to buy a lot of expensive organic chicken for dogs.  There would prob be less cruelty involved if my dogs went out and caught their own rabbits or whatever (not that they do) but at least those animals would have been free-range and had a good life!


Marrow bones are OK for mine - I used to give them raw knuckle bones from the butcher but this caused tummy probs if they consumed too much of the bone - squits and/or painful hard stools and a LOT of it. So I just give the occasional marrow bone now and give them pigs ears frequently for a dental workout.



-- Edited by Amber at 18:22, 2006-01-23

__________________
sha


Master

Status: Offline
Posts: 120
Date:
Permalink Closed

Hi


I am a great advocate for BARF diet. I have fed my dogs and cats this way for many years now and have had NO probs. But hey "each to their own".


Can i just say WATCH "rawhide" chews!!!!! Beanie my one year old Whippet choked badly on one of these a few weeks ago. It seems once they have chewed them for a while they become soft/sludgey/sticky (does that make sense?). She is ok now but Paul had to hold her upside down whilst i managed to hook my finger round it at the back of her throat to remove it. We were VERY lucky. Afterwards when things calmed down (with the help of a bottle of wine - again lol) i wondered if i`d did the right thing??? I could have lodged it further into her throat.


What i`m trying to say is how are you supposed to "safely" remove bones etc when a dog is choking big style???? Suzanne help!!!!!!!!


I will NEVER give my dogs Rawhide EVER again!


Sha



__________________
Qui me amat, amet et canem meum !
C_J


Master

Status: Offline
Posts: 327
Date:
Permalink Closed

Unfortunately the only dog I saw, while working at a vets, that came in for choking on a rawhide chew was dead on arrival.

You might think I am mad after seeing the dead dog come into my work but rawhide chews are the only chews I give Casper, I always make sure I am in the room when he gets one and I check there are no bits left if I go out.

Sha, I found this bit below on an vet website, looks like you did the right thing. It must have been scary. Well done for acting so fast.


If you notice your pet is choking, remove any item that may be constricting the neck. Examine inside the mouth and remove any foreign object you see. Do not blindly place your hand down your pet’s throat and pull any object you feel. Dogs and cats have small bones that support the base of their tongues. Owners probing the throat for a foreign object have mistaken these for chicken bones. Do not attempt to remove an object unless you can see and identify it.

If you cannot easily remove the object, lift and suspend a small animal with the head pointed down. For larger animals, lift the rear legs so the head is tilted down. This can help dislodge an item stuck in the throat.

Another method is to administer a sharp hit with the palm of your hand between the shoulder blades. This can sometimes dislodge an object.

If this does not work, a modified Heimlich maneuver can be attempted. Grasp the animal around the waist so that the rear is nearest to you, similar to a bear hug. Place a fist just behind the ribs. Compress the abdomen several times (usually 3 to 5 times) with quick pushes. Check the mouth to see if the foreign object has been removed.

Even if you are successful in removing a foreign object, veterinary examination is recommended. Internal injury could have occurred that you may not realize.


__________________
"We make a living by what we get, we make a life by what we give."
sha


Master

Status: Offline
Posts: 120
Date:
Permalink Closed

Hi


Really helpful info - thanks so much girls. There have been a few occasions when i`ve wanted to choke wee Beanie myself lol!


Seriously - i was sooooo scared, not a nice experience but we all know how to handle it properly now!


Sha x



__________________
Qui me amat, amet et canem meum !


Master

Status: Offline
Posts: 124
Date:
Permalink Closed

I used to feed my 3 greyhounds marrowbones from the butchers but soon discovered that it caused them to get excessive worms.


I would never dream of giving them chicken bones etc due to the fact the bones could well get stuck in there throats.


Now i give them wee treaty gravy bones, smachos (sp) & frolics as treats.


That is my opinion


 



__________________


Also mummy to my 2 lovely horses Perrie & Duffy


Also have my own horse forum: www.perriessite.proboards57.com
Come & join us !!!


Big Cheese

Status: Offline
Posts: 774
Date:
Permalink Closed

Interesting reading everyone's views on feeding raw bones. I was thinking of getting my 3 bones from the butchers the other day. I actually got as far as going in and asking but he said he wouldnt have any until next week. I think my dogs would love fresh meaty bones as opposed to rawhide chews. Having read all these posts im not sure if i will or not now. I could give it a go once and if it doesnt agree with them i'll just not do it again.  My next door neighbour has two pups and he has left bones lying out in the garden and when i let my dogs out (shared garden) Millie always goes to find the bones.

__________________
"Adopting just one Greyhound won't change the world, but the world will surely change for that one Greyhound."
FAJ


Enlightened One

Status: Offline
Posts: 1288
Date:
Permalink Closed

We've given our two meaty bones from the village butchers and they absolutely love, love, love them! Pearly gives up after 2 hours of gnawing, but Harry would keep going all day. They get so tired with all the chomping that it's like taking them for a long walk.

However, we're swithering about whether to do it again. Last time, they both seemed to be a bit constipated. Their poops were brick hard and it took them 3 'goes' to get back to a more normal consistency. There's no doubt that they love their bones and it cleans up their teeth a treat, but we're not sure if the effect on their tummies is worth it.

__________________
Disorder, panic, chaos; my work here is done.
sha


Master

Status: Offline
Posts: 120
Date:
Permalink Closed

Hi fiona


Dogs on barf diet will always have less poo than normal and it will usually be "compacted".


look at it as a way of "expressing their anal glands"  and cleaning their teeth - dogs on barf diet don`t pong as much! i put corn oil in my dogs food - stops the compaction prob and gives em a nice shiny coat!


so pleased you give your dogs a bone!


Sha



__________________
Qui me amat, amet et canem meum !


Big Cheese

Status: Offline
Posts: 834
Date:
Permalink Closed

I just brought a massive bone cut in 2 back from the butchers for Ziggy and Vernon. It is a big hit. Each half is bigger than their head!!

Vernon is still at it but Ziggy is having a nap as he is knackered after all the knawing.

Any dogs my family had were given bones fairly regularly and I think they are great for their teeth.

I feed a complete food but I think a nice tasty bone is a fab treat providing it is raw.


__________________


Big Cheese

Status: Offline
Posts: 774
Date:
Permalink Closed

I got mine a bone each from the butchers last week but they were sick for days after. Not really ill, just bringing up bits of bone that they obviously couldnt digest. They loved eating the bones but not sure i can be bothered with them being sick for days

__________________
"Adopting just one Greyhound won't change the world, but the world will surely change for that one Greyhound."
FAJ


Enlightened One

Status: Offline
Posts: 1288
Date:
Permalink Closed

Harry and Pearly don't really eat the bones, they gnaw off all the meat and stuff and lick out the marrow. They're never sick afterwards, but there is the issue of solid poop!

__________________
Disorder, panic, chaos; my work here is done.


Master

Status: Offline
Posts: 420
Date:
Permalink Closed

I fed raw bones to my lot once and afterwards I couldn't believe the size of the lump of bone Luca brought up in the middle of the night. I'm really surprised it didn't choke him.  Never again!

__________________
What have they done now?


Old Hand

Status: Offline
Posts: 56
Date:
Permalink Closed

I thought you weren't supposed to give greyhounds raw flesh or bones with raw flesh on them as it might increase their hunting instinct?


I wouldn't feed chicken bones, too easy to choke on as I imagine they would wolf them down if they're anything like Kayri when she gets a whiff of chicken.


Hazel.x



__________________


Master

Status: Offline
Posts: 296
Date:
Permalink Closed

I do very occasionally give my two a large marrow bone from the butchers but never ever feed them raw food. I was told by my vet that if a dog is fed on cooked/processed food etc, the bacteria built up in the stomach will not be able to break down raw food/meat and vice versa, which causes upset stomach, vomitting etc.


And as far as the the bones go, they chew on them a bit, pull out the marrow but never actually break off the bone and swallow bits. They get fed up with them very quickly.



__________________


Master

Status: Offline
Posts: 103
Date:
Permalink Closed

I thought you weren't supposed to give greyhounds raw flesh or bones with raw flesh on them as it might increase their hunting instinc

I reckon that if you dragged an entire rabbit carcass through long grass on the end of a rope it might excite them a bit, but in my experience (feeding raw food to several dogs for almost 4 years) feeding raw meat is not a problem... especially with sight hounds whose hunting instincts are generally triggered by movement. Our boy Malcolm is regularly fed on raw rabbit but the first time he discovered a whole dead bunny in the park he had a half hearted attempt to eat its fur and then pretty much lost interest...

As for the bone-vomiting, its true that dogs who generally eat a processed diet are less able to digest bones when first transferring to a raw food diet (also, it is best not to mix raw meat and bones with processed food in the same feed as they are digested differently). Fortunately dogs are designed to eat quickly without chewing much and also to eject any objects that haven't been properly digested, much like an owl pellet. And if it fit in the first time, it will fit out the next time!

Some of our lot occasionally will eject a few bits of bone, but will generally view this as a second chance to chew them up a bit before swallowing them down again!

We have been feeding our dogs raw chicken wings for breakfast most days and they soon learn to crunch them up a few times before swallowing, even the greedy ones. In fact they all took a while to try different approaches until they got the hang of crunching with the back teeth to break up the bones. Any bits of bone that pass through the system are cunningly presented lengthways and wrapped in poo so as not to damage the intestines so even if they swallow the chicken wings down whole they seem to cope fine.

We tend to avoid hard bones like lamb shanks, preferring lamb and beef ribs that the dogs can crunch up. The beef ribs are particularly good value as the dogs can spend hours chewing away at them after the meat has gone. I suspect that marrow bones are probably a little rich which may explain dodgy tummies, but beef ribs may be a better way to start your dogs with raw meat and bones. Just don't let them inside the house unless you favour slaughterhouse chic!

It is probably also worth mentioning that dogs naturally get around 30% of their diet from fruit and vegetables (and without this they can get hard faeces, which might explain Fiona's solid poop). Much of this will be the stomach contents of herbivores, which also contains that good bacteria that they are always banging on about on the telly... most dogs will tuck into horse dung, etc which fills a similar role and is beneficial unless the horse has ben recently wormed. Just don't let your dog lick your face afterwards!... they also eat grass, windfall fruits, etc. In most cases they prefer the fruit and veg to be broken down by natural processes such as rotting or pre-digestion (thanks Mr Cow!) and we replicate this by mixing a combination of pulped fruit and veg (which has passed through a juicer) with our dogs' evening meal of minced meat and chunks. It does take a wee while but we do it once a week and freeze it in batches. As a side benefit Jade & I get a regular healthy glass of vegetable juice!


__________________
FAJ


Enlightened One

Status: Offline
Posts: 1288
Date:
Permalink Closed

Dino, that's really interesting stuff. Especially about the what-goes-down-comes-out rule. Pearly once nabbed a chicken thigh when my back was turned and swallowed it whole. She puked up the whole bone the next day (don't ask me how I know this.....) and was absolutely fine.

So if we give them a marrowbone again in future, we should put some steamed vegetables or similar on their dinner in the evening? Would that ease the compaction?

__________________
Disorder, panic, chaos; my work here is done.


Master

Status: Offline
Posts: 103
Date:
Permalink Closed

Good idea, Fiona. A bit of steamed veg should do the trick!

Top Tip: I find that even vegie-hating dogs will scoff down steamed broccolli or cauliflower if its tossed in a bit of butter (a good way to use the off-cuts such as cauli leaves and stems as well)... cut the veg into small pieces to aid digestion.

__________________


Master

Status: Offline
Posts: 103
Date:
Permalink Closed

... of course the veg and bones would need to be fed at around the same time or you will probably just get stripey poo with a hard bit and a soft bit!

__________________
FAJ


Enlightened One

Status: Offline
Posts: 1288
Date:
Permalink Closed


dinomartino wrote:

... of course the veg and bones would need to be fed at around the same time or you will probably just get stripey poo with a hard bit and a soft bit!



What an appealing thought.....


__________________
Disorder, panic, chaos; my work here is done.
Page 1 of 1  sorted by
 
Quick Reply

Please log in to post quick replies.

Tweet this page Post to Digg Post to Del.icio.us


Create your own FREE Forum
Report Abuse
Powered by ActiveBoard